Right, the meat of this post has been sitting here untouched for a long time, but today's Lancet special on "increasing value, reducing waste" finally made me complete it.
It may have been the best available system in the 17th and even still in the 19th century, as Michael Eisen points out in his look into the Past, Present and Future of Scholarly Publishing. And I agree with him that in the age of the internet, insisting on the traditional model actually blocks access to research instead of promoting it. Scientists feel they need publications in high impact journals so much, their fear of being scooped actually prevents them from talking about their current research.
My own idea is even more radical than the open access strategy promoted by Eisen. I asked myself, what added value does the scientific paper itself, not just its publication in a specific journal, even provide compared to the scientists' original data?
In the times of printed journals, some condensation was obviously necessary: Mail services couldn't be expected to regularly transport everyone's collected lab books across the globe, without the recipients even being able to annotate and cross-link them. But the internet has room for quite a bit more data than the Proceedings of Scholarly Societies of yore, and I'd say we've even learned to extract meaning from such masses of data over the past few years.
So if we could start at square one right now, I think it would be possible to require scientists to publish all their original data in an online database, basically keeping their lab book online. Why would we need journals then? Yes, getting to just read the conclusions from data is nice sometimes, but those could be added in the same framework, whenever the scientists felt secure to draw some new ones from their data. And I would want to incorporate the possibility to directly link to any feedback from other scientists, like that already provided on blogs or via twitter nowadays. I'm definitely no expert on databases, but it must be possible to create a system of links that keeps track of each individual's contribution in a system like that. This would allow scientists to gain reputation from their comments, encouraging a kind of post-publication peer review. And they could draw conclusions from aggregates of others' data much more easily - truly standing on the shoulders of giants, not just walking in their footprints.
On the other hand, this system would deprive the scientific community of the simple shorthand for relevance that a publication in Nature/Science/Cell provides. Alright, that's actually its major advantage in my eyes. After all, what business do those journals have judging science by journalistic criteria? That just muddles the two domains - and infringes on what should be my job!
I'm not aware of companies writing papers in specialist journals about their latest products, of politicians trying to disseminate their programs that way. Instead, if they have something they think the public should know about, they invite dedicated business or political journalists and show them their original data (or as little of it as they think they can get away with). It's then the journalists' job to dig deeper, to put it into context, including other points of view.
Why shouldn't this system work for science journalism, too? When you think you have interesting results, invite journalists for a press conference and show them the data. The good ones will ask your colleagues for a critical appraisal and contextualization anyways, they don't need a peer reviewed paper to do so. And the bad ones - or those general journalists who just don't have time for more - are already just copying your press releases.
A database system could also keep track of those media reports and reactions, allowing scientists to monitor possible misunderstandings in general media. And those who take it upon themselves to clarify them might even get some extra recognition out of that.
Of course, a system like that would need funding, even if we could actually start from scratch. As it is, we'd have to find a workaround for incorporating "old", copyrighted research, too. So yeah - pretty much a pipe dream!
In the times of printed journals, some condensation was obviously necessary: Mail services couldn't be expected to regularly transport everyone's collected lab books across the globe, without the recipients even being able to annotate and cross-link them. But the internet has room for quite a bit more data than the Proceedings of Scholarly Societies of yore, and I'd say we've even learned to extract meaning from such masses of data over the past few years.
So if we could start at square one right now, I think it would be possible to require scientists to publish all their original data in an online database, basically keeping their lab book online. Why would we need journals then? Yes, getting to just read the conclusions from data is nice sometimes, but those could be added in the same framework, whenever the scientists felt secure to draw some new ones from their data. And I would want to incorporate the possibility to directly link to any feedback from other scientists, like that already provided on blogs or via twitter nowadays. I'm definitely no expert on databases, but it must be possible to create a system of links that keeps track of each individual's contribution in a system like that. This would allow scientists to gain reputation from their comments, encouraging a kind of post-publication peer review. And they could draw conclusions from aggregates of others' data much more easily - truly standing on the shoulders of giants, not just walking in their footprints.
On the other hand, this system would deprive the scientific community of the simple shorthand for relevance that a publication in Nature/Science/Cell provides. Alright, that's actually its major advantage in my eyes. After all, what business do those journals have judging science by journalistic criteria? That just muddles the two domains - and infringes on what should be my job!
I'm not aware of companies writing papers in specialist journals about their latest products, of politicians trying to disseminate their programs that way. Instead, if they have something they think the public should know about, they invite dedicated business or political journalists and show them their original data (or as little of it as they think they can get away with). It's then the journalists' job to dig deeper, to put it into context, including other points of view.
Why shouldn't this system work for science journalism, too? When you think you have interesting results, invite journalists for a press conference and show them the data. The good ones will ask your colleagues for a critical appraisal and contextualization anyways, they don't need a peer reviewed paper to do so. And the bad ones - or those general journalists who just don't have time for more - are already just copying your press releases.
A database system could also keep track of those media reports and reactions, allowing scientists to monitor possible misunderstandings in general media. And those who take it upon themselves to clarify them might even get some extra recognition out of that.
Of course, a system like that would need funding, even if we could actually start from scratch. As it is, we'd have to find a workaround for incorporating "old", copyrighted research, too. So yeah - pretty much a pipe dream!
Keine Kommentare:
Kommentar veröffentlichen